Do Hatchery Fish Spawn in the Wild?

Here we go again.  Blogosphere Google searches seeking information.

Q:  Do hatchery fish spawn in wild

A: Why yes they do.

Sometimes.

Not always.

Sometimes hatchery fish simply die before they mature sexually and are therefore unable to spawn in the wild.  Sometimes this death occurs as a consequence of actually being caught and “retained” by an angler, as intended. So that pretty much negates any possibility of spawning in the wild.

Sometimes the hatchery fish do not get caught, don’t die, and do in fact spawn, either with other hatchery fish or with wild fish.

Sometimes the offspring of the hatchery fish survive and themselves reach maturity and spawn.

Sometimes the offspring of hatchery fish live for a portion of their life cycle and then die before spawning.  Studies of the effectiveness of hatchery fish spawning in the wild, compared to wild native fish spawning – a mouthful – usually show that the hatchery fish are not as productive (i.e., they express lower fitness) than the wild fish spawning in the same stream.

There are some examples where hatchery salmon or steelhead that escaped from net-pens have established “wild” naturally produced runs, but these are, to the best of my knowledge, principally in places where the salmon are exotic (not native) and in these places, and the exotic salmon have decimated any native fishes that were present in the streams.

Bedazzled and confused by my oversimplifications?  You should be.  The matter is complicated.

Beware of simple, one-size-fits-all answers.

JN

One thought on “Do Hatchery Fish Spawn in the Wild?

  1. Well said, sir. Well said.

    It is key to remember that it is truly a basin-to-basin issue, and varies widely between hatchery stock origin, run-timing, degree of “hybridization”, etc… blah blah blah, yadda yadda yadda.

    As an example, take the Necanicum River. 60k – 80k smolts form the N Fk Nehalem hatchery (out-of-basin transfer) are planted annually. There is no hatchery on the Necanicum, so those fish return and spawn in a major tributary, and to some extent in the mainstem. 90% of the hatchery steelhead I landed this winter were kelts. There are also wild fish that run at the same time, that are similarly proportioned, and disticntly different from the large wild fish (let’s call them native, just for fun. I don’t have the genetic documentation handy) that show up in late March & spawn in May… So are these hybrids? Are they hatchery steelhead progeny?? Has there always been an earlier run of wild fish that just happens to coincide with the hatchery run now???

    I have set my sights on finding out…

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s